“A Good Broth Can Raise The Dead”

-South American Proverb

“Without it, nothing can be done” – Auguste Escoffier, French Chef

Every traditional culture on earth includes some sort of soup or broth made with the bones of an animal.  The French use it as a foundation for many sauces.  Certain tribes of Native Americans would give the children bones to suck the marrow out, as did the people in some parts of Italy – I know my Dad did growing up!  In Scotland 50 years ago people would “pass the bone” (no, not that kind), meaning that they would pass a bone from house to house until you couldn’t make any more broth from it.  “Jewish Penicillin” is a soup that contains the bones of the chicken.  Even in America, home-made chicken noodle soup was once considered the go-to healing meal for anyone with a cold or flu – unfortunately, processed, store bought soup isn’t curing anyone, and many of us aren’t getting any of the benefits that this superfood has to offer.


Why is this such an important dietary staple?

Let’s look at what’s in soups containing bones (broken, preferably, to release marrow):

Glycosaminoglycans  ever heard of the supplement glucosamine?  Glucosamine is one molecule that has is used as a supplement to treat arthritis in recent years, in some cases helping to regrow cartilage.  Glucosamine is one subset of the collagen-building molecules glycosaminoglycans.  These molecules actually survive digestion and go straight to the joints, repairing the tissues around them – tendons, ligaments, and the ends of bones (all made of collagen).  While scientists do not currently undersand how they know where they need to go, our ancestors have understood this for thousands of years, as it has been a staple in so many cultures for so long.  Additionally, these molecules aid the building and rebuilding of bone, hair, skin and arteries.

Broth beats the pill form of glucosamine for several reasons: It contains the full spectrum of molecules that glucosamine is only a small part of, and it does not undergo the high heat processing that pills undergo, which often ruin or lessen the nutrients in a given substance.  It also gives you calcium and minerals needed to absorb that calcium as an added benefit.

Omega 3 DHA Fatty Acids – help build nerve, brain and bone tissue, as well as strengthening immunity.

Amino Acids  bone contains as much as 6x the amount of glycine that muscle meat contains.  Also contains arginine and proline.

Magnesium – this mineral will receive its own post on the blog due to its importance for so many bodily functions.  Among them are “guarding” the channels by which calcium enters the bones – meaning that if magnesium is not present in the body, calcium cannot be absorbed by the bones.  It is also a factor in over 300 enzyme systems that regulate reactions in the body, including those required for muscle and nerve function, glycolysis and energy production.

Phosphorous – required to build healthy bones and teeth, and to create ATP (energy).

Silicon – required for healthy eyes, tendons, skin and arteries.

Sulphur – required to build collagen, keratin (for healthy nails/hair) and for respiration.

Calcium – it has been debated whether or not there is a substantial amount of calcium in bone broth.  However, it is worth noting here even if it is not a large amount, because due to the presence of the aforementioned minerals, whatever calcium exists in the broth will be readily absorbed by the body.

In short, it’s really, really good for your tendons, ligaments, joints and bones.  Sound like something an athlete wants in their diet?

So, unless you can secure stock from a source that you know uses actual bones and avoids using the high heat used to over-process (and ruin) the aforementioned nutritional benefits, you may be wondering how to make your own.  It may sound a little complicated, but it is actually quite cheap and easy.  It will take some time to cook, so if you do not have one, I’d recommend a crockpot so that you can just toss everything in and wait, not worrying about a flame on in your house.  If not, a giant soup pot will do.

IMG_0282  (stock selfie)

Sam’s Homemade Chicken Stock – adapted from Ina Garten’s recipe, with suggestions to maximize nutritional value from Dr. Cate Shanahan


1-2 pounds chicken bones – cracked to release marrow – you can find them in Whole Foods for a dollar a pound.  You can also keep bones from previously cooked chicken dishes.  Better to use organic because a healthy animal is a healthier meal, but I don’t always.  I prefer to buy at Mayflower Poultry in Cambridge, MA, because they also sell Chicken Feet.

3-4 chicken feet – I was once told by an older Chinese man that making soup with this is like “sticking an IV in your vein.”  Very rich source of collagen, feet have been used for healing and health in China for thousands of years.  Tyson chicken actually exports the feet that they don’t use over to China to be sold.  Be sure to scrub them before you use them.

photo 1

2 cups white wine or some sort of vinegar – this, along with the following three acidic vegetables, will help to leach extra calcium out of the bones you are using.

3 large yellow onions, unpeeled and quartered
6 carrots, unpeeled and halved
4 stalks celery with leaves, cut into thirds
20 sprigs fresh parsley
15 sprigs fresh thyme
20 sprigs fresh dill
1 head garlic, unpeeled and cut in 1/2 crosswise
2 tablespoons kosher salt
2 teaspoons whole black peppercorns

Step 1:  Put bones, feet, wine/vinegar and veggies into the crock or stove pot.  Pour cold water over it, up to the top (some will evaporate), bring to a boil, and turn down the heat.  If using a crockpot, putting it on low will do just fine.  I leave it uncovered so that it can evaporate and so that I can remember to skim the fat off of the top when it rises up there, but it’s debatable if you need to cover it or not.  Leave no warmer than a slight bubble (NOT BOILING unless you want rancid stock) for 17 hours (some western chefs cook for much less than this – however being determined to maximize the nutritional benefit I go the full 18 I have heard from a practitioner of traditional Chinese medicine).


Step 2:  Add herbs etc. to the pot – you can add them at the beginning but they’ll lose their flavor.

Step 3:  Let sit another hour, then let it cool before straining the stock into a big bowl.  If you put it in too warm it may ruin other things in the fridge…just a warning.

Step 4:  Take it out of the fridge, strain it through a cheesecloth if you would like a more even consistency, and pour your earnings into mason jars to store it!  I keep one jar in the fridge (will be good for a week or so), and the rest in the freezer (can keep for a few months).  Keep a little space at the top when filling jars because broth expands as it freezes.

photo 2

Use as a base for soups, or in place of some or all of the water for making things such as rice, quinoa, buckwheat – I actually find the flavor preferable to using water.

As for the expense:

The veggies and herbs I usually pick up at Trader Joe’s, usually costing me under $10.  Because of the way that they are sold, I usually come home with twice as much as I need for this recipe, so I will make stock twice within a week and have stock for 4-6 weeks (and I use a lot of it).  Chicken bones and feet are usually a dollar a pound or cheaper, so we’ll say $2.50.  So $12.50 for the base of a lot of what I do in the kitchen for 4-6 weeks.  I usually use at least a cup and half a day in something or rather…so that’s around $.29-$.44 per serving…a worthwhile investment given the above information.



Above: Soup made by roasting olive oil, parsley and garlic in one saucepan for a couple minutes before adding chickpeas, covering the pot and cooking 12-15 minutes, while cooking the aforementioned broth, onions, broccoli, salt, pepper and grass-fed butter in the other for the same amount of time, before combining for the last five minutes.  On the side is organic whole milk yogurt with apple and chia seeds.


“Deep Nutrition” by Dr. Catherine Shanahan

“Healing with Whole Foods” by Paul Pitchford

Weston A. Price Foundation, westonaprice.org

Ina Garten’s Chicken Stock:  http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/ina-garten/chicken-stock-recipe.html


5 thoughts on ““A Good Broth Can Raise The Dead”

  1. joe1212 says:

    Hey Sam! Thanks for this great post! Where would you recommend to go and try find chicken feet from? If you can’t find chicken feet, would using left over bones from rotisserie chicken, ribs, or other meats be suitable replacement?


    • Sam! says:

      Hi Joe! While feet seem to be the best source of collagen, any bones will do – however those with joints, such as a leg or necks/backs are typically valued because they contain quite a bit of collagen as well. As for how to find it, find a butcher that handles the whole bird. Often there are specialty butcher shops where they either sell feet/every part of the chicken, or you can ask them to save you some if they typically sell them or use them otherwise. To find a butcher, I’d try google first, but after that I’d ask a local grocery store where they find their meat – the chicken has to come from somewhere!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s